.png)
Selecting the right private medical college in India is a critical decision that directly impacts academic quality, clinical exposure, and long-term career outcomes. Among private MBBS colleges in Uttarakhand, Himalayan Institute of Medical Sciences (HIMS), Dehradun and Shri Guru Ram Rai Institute of Medical & Health Sciences (SGRR), Dehradun are two widely preferred options for Indian students.
This article presents a clear cost–benefit comparison to help students and parents choose wisely.
1. College Overview
Himalayan Institute of Medical Sciences (HIMS) functions under Swami Rama Himalayan University and is known for its large teaching hospital, strong clinical departments, and research-oriented academic culture.
SGRR Medical College, affiliated with Shri Guru Ram Rai University, is respected for its modern infrastructure, focused academic environment, and consistent MBBS results.
Both colleges are approved by the National Medical Commission (NMC) and listed in the World Directory of Medical Schools (WDOMS), ensuring degree validity in India and abroad.
Many students compare such institutions with the help of MBBS Advisor to understand real costs, exposure, and outcomes before admission.
2. Fee Structure & Cost Comparison
HIMS Dehradun
- Total MBBS cost usually crosses ?1 crore
- Additional charges for hostel, examinations, and university services
SGRR Dehradun
- Overall MBBS cost is slightly lower than HIMS
- Still expensive but marginally more affordable
Cost Verdict:
SGRR Dehradun offers a better cost advantage, while HIMS requires a higher financial commitment.
3. Infrastructure & Campus Facilities
HIMS
- Large university campus
- Advanced laboratories and research facilities
- Multi-specialty tertiary-care hospital
SGRR
- Compact yet modern campus
- Well-equipped classrooms and laboratories
- Efficient hospital infrastructure
Infrastructure Verdict:
HIMS excels in scale and research scope, while SGRR delivers efficient facilities within a focused medical setup.
4. Clinical Exposure & Hospital Training
HIMS
- High patient inflow
- Exposure to complex and diverse medical cases
- Strong hands-on clinical learning
SGRR
- Adequate patient load
- Structured supervision during clinical postings
- Sufficient exposure for MBBS-level training
Clinical Verdict:
HIMS provides relatively stronger clinical exposure, especially for students targeting competitive postgraduate paths.
5. Recognition & Licensing Eligibility
Graduates from both colleges are eligible to appear for licensing and postgraduate examinations because the institutions are recognized by:
- National Medical Commission (NMC)
- World Health Organization (WHO)
- World Directory of Medical Schools (WDOMS)
This recognition allows students to pursue medical practice, PG courses, and international licensing exams after MBBS.
6. Return on Investment (ROI)
HIMS
- Higher fees result in slower ROI
- Strong academic environment may benefit exam preparation
SGRR
- Slightly lower fees improve ROI
- Balanced academics and clinical exposure
ROI Verdict:
SGRR Dehradun offers a better cost-to-benefit ratio for most students.
7. Student Life & Campus Environment
Both colleges provide:
- Separate hostels for boys and girls
- Secure and disciplined campuses
- Academic and student support systems
HIMS offers a broader university-style environment, while SGRR maintains a more focused medical-college atmosphere.
Final Comparison Summary
|
Aspect |
HIMS Dehradun |
SGRR Dehradun |
|
Total Cost |
Higher |
Lower |
|
Clinical Exposure |
Strong |
Good |
|
Infrastructure |
Large & Advanced |
Modern & Efficient |
|
Recognition |
NMC, WHO, WDOMS |
NMC, WHO, WDOMS |
|
ROI |
Moderate |
Better |
Conclusion
Both Himalayan Institute and SGRR Dehradun are reputable MBBS options in India. Students seeking extensive clinical exposure and research orientation may prefer HIMS, while those prioritizing affordability with solid training may find SGRR more suitable.
For transparent comparisons, fee clarity, and personalized counselling, many students rely on MBBS Advisor before finalizing their medical college choice.
